Kate (kate_nepveu) wrote,

FMA end-of-series thought/poll (spoilers)

Free-assocation musing about the end of Fullmetal Alchemist; series-ruining spoilers and a poll behind the cut.

Springing in tenuous ways from untrue_accounts's drabble "Gold", I found myself wondering: Al chooses to sacrifice himself to bring Ed back. He makes a point of saying that it's his choice to do so. He's given Ed back his life, at the cost of his own.

Did Ed, by then giving up his life in favor of resurrecting Al, fail to respect Al's choice? Did he have an obligation to not squander Al's gift?

I don't think I have an answer or opinion on this just now (and I don't think I'm expressing myself well, because I'm very sleepy), but it struck me as an interesting thought. I'd love to teach FMA and assign it as a final essay. =>

In lieu of that, a poll:

Al brought Ed back to life; Ed then offered up his life to bring Al back to life. Besides being worryingly circular if continued, this was:

the right thing for Ed to do.
an acceptable thing for Ed to do.
the wrong thing for Ed to do.
something else, described in a comment.

Tags: anime, fullmetal alchemist, poll

  • lazyweb inquiry: new desktop PC

    So I'm buying a new desktop PC because the one I'm using now is sad and slow. What's the general configuration of a lower-middle-end machine these…

  • Yuletide 2009 recommendations

    I have recommendations from 2009's Yuletide rare-fandom fanfic exchange, only six months late! These are all stories that I think are (a) very…

  • some more short fiction

    Some more Hugo-eligible short fiction that I've read and liked: "Three Twilight Tales," Jo Walton, Firebirds Soaring (mostly not in bookstores any…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded