Kate (kate_nepveu) wrote,
Kate
kate_nepveu

Week in Review

We bought and put up our tree today. It seemed to have a few thick branches and a lot of thin ones, which made distributing the ornaments a challenge, but it looks nice. Chad's talking about doing another "science on the tree" series, so watch this space. Or his, I suppose.

Last night, we went to see The Golden Compass. Short version: I agree with most reviewers who say that the look of the film and the actress playing Lyra are great, but the pace is too fast. (As various people have said, this is a big-budget movie based on a fantasy novel coming out from New Line in December. It's allowed to be more than two hours.) I will add that the shortened pace leads to some anvilicious exposition, which I haven't seen any reviewers say, but they're probably not allowed to say "anvilicious" in print reviews. Enjoyable, but kind of exhausting.

Spoilery version:

In no particular order:

  • The most obvious pace problem was the revelation of Mrs. Coulter's involvement in the kidnappings, where Lyra sees the words "General Oblation Board" and immediately jumps to the conclusion that they are the Gobblers, without even seeing the list of children's names further down the page. Yeah, right.
  • The intercision reveal wasn't scary enough.
  • The CGI was generally good. Something was off about Pan as a cat, and I've yet to see a closeup of raptors' wings that looked right to me, but mostly it was seamless.
  • I found it too distracting to have Ian McKellen as the voice of Iorek, though Chad mostly didn't mind.
  • I understand why the movie stopped short of the book's ending, and moved the panserbjørne confrontation before the big rescue—when the studio hasn't committed to filming the rest of the trilogy, it's not fair to end on a cliffhanger like that, and so making the rescue the climax makes sense. The result, though, is almost more dramatic irony that I could stand. (And does lead to a plot hole, of why Iorek went alone to the experimental station.)

We got a mostly dire batch of trailers, though The Spiderwick Chronicles continues to look promising, and Inkheart might be good—Andy Serkis in a main role. (I haven't read the book yet. Either of the books, actually, though Spiderwick isn't high on my list.)

And now, a selection of links, starting with two about His Dark Materials, then more entertainment, politics, and seasonal stuff (holidays and otherwise).

Tags: [time] in review, fanfic, links, movies
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 20 comments