Kate (kate_nepveu) wrote,
Kate
kate_nepveu

SPOILERS: Deerskin by Robin McKinley

Over on my book log, I've just posted a comment on Deerskin, by Robin McKinley, in which I talk around some problems I had with the book. For the curious, I put spoilers behind the cut tag. This will probably not make any sense at all if you haven't read the book.

My problem with the magical help is this quote (page 226, Ace paperback):

She had lived. They were now only memories, and where she stood now the sun was shining.

Five years ago.

The Moonwoman had said, I give you the gift of time.

Time enough to grow strong enough to remember. Maybe the Moonwoman had known Lissar well enough after all.

Now, if the time had been so that people wouldn't associate her with the missing/presumed dead princess of her original kingdom, fine. Makes perfect sense to me. But those years lying on the mountaintop felt as though one night for her; she didn't experience them at all. I fail to understand how the passage of time, when not experienced, allows one to grow strong. Might as well have just healed her wounds and taken her memory away, and skipped those years completely—surely it would have been the same from Lissar's point of view?

This is what I mean about psychological realism (time to grow strong) not fitting well with fairy tales (magical sleep and healing on mountaintops).

My practical questions, by the way, were: what's going to happen to the kingdom of Lissar's father, now that he's old and broken and heirless; and what about Camilla, Ossin's sister, the responsible and interesting one who was to marry said nameless king? This isn't her story, but to me she feels like she has one.

Tags: books, sff
Subscribe

  • . . . look at this as an opportunity

    I have just discovered that not only am I solo-parenting for the week after I get back from this vacation, but that daycare will be closed for two of…

  • The Hold Steady; college hockey; other people's babies

    Hello, DW. I had a very busy weekend, all of it lovely, which is nice since Thursday was, oh, let's say top three in worst courtroom experiences…

  • afternoon thunderstorm

    Today I, the kids, and the babysitter (who comes on Sunday afternoons to play with SteelyKid while Chad/I get work done/nap with the Pip/go…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 11 comments

  • . . . look at this as an opportunity

    I have just discovered that not only am I solo-parenting for the week after I get back from this vacation, but that daycare will be closed for two of…

  • The Hold Steady; college hockey; other people's babies

    Hello, DW. I had a very busy weekend, all of it lovely, which is nice since Thursday was, oh, let's say top three in worst courtroom experiences…

  • afternoon thunderstorm

    Today I, the kids, and the babysitter (who comes on Sunday afternoons to play with SteelyKid while Chad/I get work done/nap with the Pip/go…